Pope Francis and “The Meltdown of the Church”

Rorate Caeli features two articles this morning by Italian historian Roberto de Mattei – one titled the “Meltdown of the Church” and the other a response to criticism of the article. Both discuss the theological roots of the present crisis, particularly as it pertains to the present pontificate.
“The ‘school of Bologna’s victory was sealed by the election of Pope Francis, who, speaks little of the Council because he is not interested in theological discussions but in the reality of the facts, and it is in the praxis that he wants to show that he is the true accomplisher of Vatican II. Under this aspect, it could be said, he incarnates the essence of Vatican II, and makes it doctrine, by fulfilling its pastoral dimension. Theological discussion belongs to modernity and Pope Francis presents himself as a post-hermeneutic pope and thus post-modern. The battle of ideas belongs to a phase in the history of the Church which he wants to go beyond. Francis will be a conservative or a progressive, according to the historical and political demands of the moment.

The ‘pastoral revolution’ is, according to Alberto Melloni, the primary characteristic of Francis’ pontificate. ‘Pastoral’ – the Bolognese historian writes – is a key word in understanding Pope Francis’ ministry. Not because he was a teacher of pastoral theology, but because when he interprets it, Francis evokes with amazing naturalness the pulsing heart of the Gospel at the crossroads of receiving (or refusing) Vatican II. ‘Pastoral’ comes from the language of Pope John: it was thus that he wanted ‘his’ Council, – a pastoral Council – and Vatican II was just that. (L’estasi pastorale di papa Francesco disseminata di riferimenti teologici, in “Corriere della Sera”, 29 marzo 2013).

Melloni, as always, forces reality, but basically he is not wrong. The pontificate of Pope Francis is the most authentically concilar one, in which praxis is turned into doctrine, and which attempts to change the image and reality of the Church.”

“In which praxis is turned into doctrine”. Remember that phrase. For Pope Francis religion is primarily about human action and experience, about the “encounter” and the feelings thereby inspired. Christ appears as only a means to this human experience, rather than an end in Himself. Doctrine and even morality, when they seem to inhibit the kind of praxis that religious feeling and experience demand, are at best considerations to be postponed, but more usually they are just swallowed up by the all-important “encounter” and disregarded.


3 thoughts on “Pope Francis and “The Meltdown of the Church”

  1. I don’t see Pope Francis prioritizing the subjective over the objective – in this regard I don’t think he is any different from Benedict XVI or JP2 in noting that Christianity is not an encounter with doctrine but with Christ Himself.


  2. Thank you for the comment, Dr. Poterack. Of course I am aware of those two affirmations, and admit there may be even more off the record, but unfortunately the sum total of everything else he has said and done screams “rupture!”.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s